Journalist, activist and full-time Labour cheerleader Owen Jones (is there really only one of him?) thinks that socialism is on the way; Blairite Nick Cohen fears a Corbyn government; Corbyn himself has hit a plateau of confidence and security as Labour leader; the Conservatives have presided over a disastrous year of British history during the shambolic Brexit negotiations; the essential creed of Conservatism that it is the defense of property rights and other vested interests is becoming increasingly exposed each day by the fact that the mythical carrot dangling out in front of voters that they too can become part of the prosperous, unmortgaged, property-owning club without having to sell their kidneys and/or their daughters has become less and less realistic to more and more people; the Conservatives are sitting on a demographic time bomb in terms of voting intention and party membership; Labour’s grass roots base has flourished with the rise of Momentum; younger voters have been emboldened by the shit storm that is Brexit to come out and vote in greater numbers; the economy has stalled and household debt and homelessness has soared; and austerity is now hitting mainstream state provision (like primary schools, police, the NHS and firefighters) in a way that – from my own observations in a safe Conservative constituency in the south – is troubling even many traditional Conservative voters. The conclusion seems clear: Corbyn is going to be the next prime minister.
Only, for all of the things in Corbyn’s favour, the idea that there will be a Labour victory with a sizable majority still seems somehow hugely implausible. And, without it, any radical program that could even come close to being described as socialism, would be impossible. The latest polling, for instance, suggests that Labour and the Conservatives are virtually neck and neck. So why is this? The ‘S’ word is clearly a factor. Socialism is a divisive ideology as a mainstream political platform in the UK and until Jeremy Corbyn assumed the leadership of the Labour Party, the spin-doctored Labour centrists had it down on the blacklist of ‘words you should never, ever use,’ along with Militant, Trotsky, Lenin, Stalin, communism, the 1970s, the 3-day week, Arthur Scargill, miners and Clause IV. That was all part of the Blairite strategy of moving Labour firmly into the Murdoch-approved neoliberal centre ground, in which rather than being seen, in tabloid speak, as a ‘bunch of beardy lefty loons’, they might instead be positioned as competent, professional technocrats interested in ideologically nebulous concepts like social mobility and justice.
Owen Jones is aware of the toxic nature of the word ‘socialism’ in mainstream public opinion, which is why he is doing his best to reclaim it as something positive. ‘Socialism will liberate the individual. And here’s how,’ is his pinned tweet at the time of writing, linking to an article in the Guardian about how neoliberalism robs people of freedom because it also robs them of their security. He has history on this kind of project – his first book ‘Chavs: The Demonisation of the Working Class’, which propelled him into relative stardom – mounted a thought-provoking and passionate argument against the lazy dismissal of an entire section of society as a kind of undesirable and unwanted underclass. Many on the left, Jones included, argue that the tabloid press is one of the main problems – the tabloid world is one that is outwardly full of clichés, stereotypes and casual dismissal; and on closer examination turns out to be a concerted and relentless propaganda campaign waged by billionaire media moguls to strip people of meaningful consciousness of what is really going on in the world. Fake news, in other words.
The grip of tabloid culture on political views and voting intention and its role in enforcing a kind of cultural hegemony amongst the electorate is loosening in a much more complex and diverse media environment in which people under the age of 40 almost never buy a newspaper and social media (in itself a highly segmented and diverse channel – Facebook is as different to Snapchat as the Daily Mail is to the Guardian) takes up an ever-increasing proportion of people’s media consumption. In that sense, Labour’s prospects are looking up – in a more decentralised media environment, the plutocrats in theory should have less power and influence, though arguably both the Brexit referendum and Trump’s election have shown how the apparently heterogenous and fragmented nature of social media can also be subverted to achieve dogmatic ends that represent the interests of capital.
Regardless, I’m not sure that socialism is necessarily what people want anyway. Do a straw poll and ask people what ‘-ism’ they do want. My guess is that nine out of ten cats will tell you that they want roof-over-my-head-ism, food-on-the-table-ism, health-service-that-works-ism, good-education-for-my-kids-ism and the like. A socialist, of course, would say that his or her ideology would guarantee all this and more. But I am very sceptical of anyone trying to sell me a political creed above the real-world consequences of what that would mean for real people. The twentieth century taught us to be wary of ideologues – and, although it may reek a little of centrist dad, I think that it’s a lesson that’s well worth remembering in a time of increasing extremism on all sides of the political spectrum. Jean-Paul Lyotard famously defined the postmodern condition as a incredulity to metanarratives – in other words a rejection of sweeping discourses about the world in favour of small, localized stories. We live in this postmodern world, or what Mark Fisher called the world of capitalist realism, in which other forms of economic system are effectively unimaginable. So I’d suggest to Jones that he abandons the ‘grand narrative’ dogmatism of trying to sell socialism to the masses and instead focus on something like what Jeremy Corbyn has been doing at PMQs – finding individual instances of problems that people have and how the government may be able to make a difference by doing something that it’s not doing at the moment. Here’s an example of this:
‘I have a question from Steven, who works for a housing association. He says that the cut in rents will mean that the company that he works for will lose 150 jobs by next March because of the loss of funding for that housing association to carry on with its repairs. Down the line, that will mean worse conditions, worse maintenance, fewer people working there, and a greater problem for people living in those properties. Does the Prime Minister not think it is time to reconsider the question of the funding of the administration of housing, as well as, of course, the massive gap of 100,000 units a year between what is needed and what is being built?’
What is important is that the solutions are effective (as in providing a better quality of life for as many people as possible instead of enriching a tiny part of the population) rather than rigidly ideological in nature (the state always being the solution). The likelihood is that they will offer a direct challenge to the dominant neoliberal consensus and therefore be what you might call a ‘leftist’ policy, but in terms of selling this to the electorate, it needs to feel that it is primarily problem-solving in nature – and rooted in a value system of care, compassion and justice.
The opportunity for meaningful change comes at that point when it seems inevitable and unarguable that there needs to be a new type of social contract. And this is what I am referring to in my title when I talk about a mandate for change. It feels that this is almost within Labour’s grasp. At the end of the Second World War many people wondered what they had been fighting for if was not to have a better deal from the state in a number of different ways. Winston Churchill, who, even at the height of his own personal popularity in May 1945, understood that there was a great appetite for the state to provide a much higher level of welfare to its citizens and put him out of a job, suggested that if the British public voted for Labour, they would encounter ‘some sort of Gestapo’.
This was Labour leader Clement Attlee’s quietly impassioned response:
‘The prime minister made much play last night with the rights of the individual and the dangers of people being ordered about by officials. I entirely agree that people should have the greatest freedom compatible with the freedom of others. There was a time when employers were free to work little children for sixteen hours a day. I remember when employers were free to employ sweated women workers on finishing trousers at a penny halfpenny a pair. There was a time when people were free to neglect sanitation so that thousands died of preventable diseases. For years every attempt to remedy these crying evils was blocked by the same plea of freedom for the individual. It was in fact freedom for the rich and slavery for the poor. Make no mistake, it has only been through the power of the state, given to it by parliament, that the general public has been protected against the greed of ruthless profit-makers and property owners. The Conservative party remains as always a class party. In twenty-three years in the House of Commons, I cannot recall more than half a dozen from the ranks of the wage earners. It represents today, as in the past, the forces of property and privilege. the Labour Party is, in fact, the one party which most nearly reflects in its representation and composition all the main streams which flow into the great river of our national life.’
Attlee embraces many individual causes that his party had been successful in helping to change – things that seemed retrospectively so obviously to be the right thing to do that he created that same culture of inevitability about the Labour Party’s own right to form the next government. What he does not do is to bang the drum about socialism – indeed, he doesn’t mention it.
Twenty-year-old RAF pilot Tony Benn returned from Egypt in June 1945 on the troop ship Carthage, which was also carrying many servicemen who had fought with General Slim in Burma. They decided to organize hustings on board and Benn spoke on ‘Why I will vote Labour,’ even though as a twenty-year-old he was actually ineligible to cast a vote (the voting age was then twenty-one). On that ship, on 7 June 1945, Benn said this to the troops:
‘One of the most pressing problems of all is housing. Before the war, slums were a running sore – disease and squalor were rampant in many areas. the submerged tenth were a forgotten minority. The position now is even more serious than it was then. Inability to effect ordinary repairs and the damage caused by enemy action is incalculable. Are we going to let Jerry builder do his worst and breed a new series of slums for the next generation, or are we going to plan decent homes for the future.’
Labour promised food, work and homes, full employment and a national health service. Out of the bombed ruins of Britain’s cities, they planned to build a New Jerusalem. Their motto was: ‘Let us face the future.’
Likewise, Labour now should not be trying to sell the British people an ideology; they should be creating the conditions in which meaningful social change can take place and establishing that same sense of inevitability which existed at the end of the Second World War. That may not be socialism – many on the harder left would argue that a much better and less austere welfare state is capitalism’s greatest weapon against genuine socialism (and a form of accelerationism would suggest that austerity is actually a positive weapon in bringing people to genuine consciousness about the reality in which they live – see for instance the popularity of I, Daniel Blake as a consciousness-raising meme only made possible by brutal welfare policies) – but a new political direction which not only has a sense of basic decency and compassion, but which is also able to deliver the benefits of this outlook to as many people as possible, feels like it would be a positive development in this country’s recently disastrous national life. I don’t think that has to revolve around a conscious self-identification with leftist politics (in fact it would be better not to) – instead, it has more to do with a determination that there can be a better way of life for the majority of people in this country. And the moment that breaks out of a sense of political tribalism and into the mainstream is the moment that Labour does get a mandate for change.
Kudos. A lot of data!
https://nicktambone.com/
king pharmacy
canadianpharmacy
canadian prescription drugs
canada drug
Incredible plenty of very good info!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
pharmacy prices canada drugs best canadian prescription prices canada pharmacy online
no prescription pharmacy
no prescription pharmacies
best canadian pharmacies
trust pharmacy canada
onlinecanadianpharmacy.com
online pharmacy no prescription needed
Great knowledge. Regards!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canada pharmacies online pharmacies canada canada pharmacies online prescriptions london drugs canada
global pharmacy canada
meds online
candrugstore com
canadapharmacy
canada pharmacies
online pharmacies no prescription
Whoa plenty of amazing knowledge.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
prescription drugs without prior prescription canada pharmaceuticals online drug costs canadian pharmacy
mail order pharmacy
cheap prescription drugs
drug costs
drugs for sale
best online pharmacy stores
canadian drugstore
You revealed that wonderfully.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
compare prescription prices canada drugs online price prescription drugs canadian online pharmacy
mail order pharmacies
canada drugs online
online pharmacy without prescription
canadian pharmacy online canada
overseas pharmacies
canadian pharmacy
Kudos! I enjoy it.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
best online international pharmacies canada drugs buy prescription drugs canada canadian pharmacies-24h
cheap drugs online
best online pharmacy
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
canadian rx pharmacy online
drugstore online
canadian drugstore online
You actually reported it very well.
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
online rx pharmacy canada pharmacy online pharmacies no prescription canadian pharmacies online
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
best non prescription online pharmacies
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
prescription price comparison
online canadian pharmacies
canadian pharma companies
You said it adequately.!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canada meds london drugs canada best online pharmacies no prescription canadianpharmacy
pharmacy drug store
prescription drug price comparison
best canadian pharmacies
canadadrugs
canadianpharmacy
online canadian pharmacy
Nicely put. Appreciate it.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadian cialis canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacies top best north west pharmacy canada
international pharmacy
prescription pricing
drug stores near me
canadian pharmacies online
canadian cialis
cheap prescription drugs
You’ve made your stand quite effectively!.
http://talahicc.com/
buy online prescription drugs canada online pharmacies cheap canadian drugs canadian pharmaceuticals online
canadapharmacyonline.com
prescription drug
canadapharmacyonline com
ed meds online
canada pharmacy
canada pharmacy online
You definitely made your point!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadian online pharmacy global pharmacy canada global pharmacy canada canadianpharmacy
prescription price comparison
us pharmacy no prior prescription
medical information online
online pharmacy usa
canadian meds
canadian drug
Appreciate it. A lot of content!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
northwest pharmacy canada canadian pharmacies-24h the canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy
canadian pharmacy online
online prescription drugs
best online pharmacies canada
canada drugs
canada pharmacy online reviews
canadian pharmacies online
Thank you. A lot of facts!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
get prescription online canadian pharmaceuticals online pharmacy tech london drugs canada
canadianpharmacy
visit poster’s website
cheap prescription drugs online
mexican pharmacy online
discount pharmacy
canada pharmacies online
You’ve made your point!
https://nicktambone.com/
online pharmacy canadian pharmacies-24h safe canadian online pharmacies canada pharmacy
pharmacy tech
best online pharmacy
prescription drug cost
board of pharmacy
canadian prescriptions
no prescription online pharmacy
You explained it fantastically.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
trust pharmacy canada canadian pharcharmy canadapharmacy trust pharmacy canada
trust pharmacy canada
online canadian discount pharmacy
online canadian discount pharmacy
walgreens pharmacy
canadian pharmacy
best canadian online pharmacy
You said it nicely..
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
best non prescription online pharmacies canadian pharmaceuticals online best online pharmacies no prescription canadian pharmacies online
best online pharmacies canada
pharmacy near me
best canadian online pharmacy
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
prescription pricing
prescription drug price comparison
You suggested that fantastically.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadadrugs north west pharmacy canada price prescription drugs canadian pharmacies that ship to us
drug price
top rated canadian pharmacies online
canadian pharmacy uk delivery
prescription pricing
cheap prescription drugs
online drugs
You made your position very well!.
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canadian pharmacy online canada pharmaceuticals online canadian pharcharmy online canada drugs online
medication costs
canadian drugstore reviews
us pharmacy no prior prescription
pharmacy prices compare
online drugstore
canadian meds
Thanks a lot. Lots of posts!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
discount prescription drug canadian pharmaceuticals online prescription online canada pharmacy
canadian prescription
online canadian pharcharmy
prescription without a doctor’s prescription
canadian pharmacy viagra brand
cheap prescription drugs online
mexican online pharmacies
You suggested it fantastically!
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian pharmacy no prescription top rated canadian pharmacies online best price prescription drugs canada pharmaceutical online ordering
canada pharmacy no prescription
us pharmacy no prior prescription
online pharmacy usa
online pharmacy canada
canadian cialis
price prescription drugs
Thanks a lot! Valuable information!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
mexican pharmacies online canadian online pharmacy pharmacy online store canadianpharmacy
drug stores near me
prescription drug
drugs online
buy cialis
canadian online pharmacy
prescription drugs online without
Useful write ups. Thanks.
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
prescription cost comparison canada pharmacy mexican pharmacy online medications online pharmacies canada
buy online prescription drugs
canadian discount pharmacy
rx pharmacy
drugstore online
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
canada drug
Terrific facts. Cheers!
https://nicktambone.com/
mail order pharmacy aarp approved canadian online pharmacies no prescription pharmacy canadian pharmacies without an rx
trusted overseas pharmacies
discount pharmacy online
mexican pharmacies
prescription drugs online without
canada pharmacy online reviews
canadian pharmacy reviews
Point certainly applied.!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
pharmacy online store canadian pharmacies canada pharmacies online prescriptions canada online pharmacies
prescription cost comparison
canadapharmacyonline com
pharmacies in canada
canadian online pharmacy reviews
pharmacy online store
most reliable canadian pharmacies
Superb forum posts. Kudos.
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
board of pharmacy canadian drugs no prescription pharmacy canada drugs
online pharmacies
canadianpharmacy
canada pharmacy online
no 1 canadian pharcharmy online
buying prescription drugs canada
canada pharmacy online
Seriously all kinds of awesome tips!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
rx pharmacy canadian pharmacies-24h best canadian online pharmacy northwestpharmacy
discount pharmacy online
canadian pharmacy no prescription needed
meds online
canadian pharmacy king
canadapharmacy
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
You actually reported that exceptionally well!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
prescription drugs online without canadian online pharmacy canadian pharmacies online london drugs canada
prescription drugs online without doctor
medical information online
canada drugs
canadian pharmacy
online discount pharmacy
discount pharmaceuticals
Very good info. Thanks!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canadian prescription canada drug drugs online canadianpharmacy
mail order pharmacies
canadapharmacyonline com
prescription drug cost
online discount pharmacy
best price prescription drugs
onlinecanadianpharmacy.com
Amazing tons of terrific facts.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
rx pharmacy online pharmacies of canada pharmacies near me canadian pharmacies-24h
drugs for sale
canadian viagra
pharmacies in canada
online pharmacy usa
the canadian pharmacy
pharmacy prices compare
You made your stand very effectively!.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
online canadian pharcharmy canadianpharmacy canadian drugstore online mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
canadian pharmacies that ship to us
legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
king pharmacy
pharmacy near me
mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
canadian drugstore
Kudos, Loads of advice.
https://nicktambone.com/
canadian pharmacy uk delivery canada online pharmacies rx online canadian pharmacy online
pharmacy prescription
mexican pharmacies online
canadian pharmacy online canada
canadapharmacyonline com
drug stores near me
my canadian pharmacy
You’ve made your point.
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
buy prescription drugs from canada canadian online pharmacies canadian pharmacy viagra brand aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
best price prescription drugs
compare prescription prices
no prescription pharmacies
prescription drugs prices
prescription drugs online without doctor
best non prescription online pharmacies
You actually expressed it wonderfully!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
the canadian pharmacy canada pharmacy pharmacy prices compare online pharmacies canada
reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
no prior prescription required pharmacy
online canadian discount pharmacy
pharmacy prices compare
pharmacy price compare
pain meds online without doctor prescription
Regards, I enjoy it.
http://talahicc.com/
canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs canadian pharmacies that ship to us pharmacy cost comparison canada pharmacy online
canadian prescription
canadian pharmacies
drugs from canada
pharmacy price comparison
candrugstore com
discount pharmacy
Amazing many of useful knowledge.
https://nicktambone.com/
drugs from canada canada pharmacy canadian pharmacy uk delivery canada drugs online
safeway pharmacy
online pharmacies no prescription
canadian family pharmacy
costco pharmacy pricing
prescription cost
meds online
You reported it adequately.
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
online prescription drugs canada pharmaceuticals online online drugstore canadian viagra
canadian discount pharmacy
prescription drugs online without doctor
prescription drug
drugs without prescription
canada drug
canadian pharmacy meds
Well spoken without a doubt! !
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
drugs without prescription canadian viagra pharmacy online mexico canada pharmaceuticals online
canadadrugs
canadian drugs without prescription
discount prescription drug
canadian rx pharmacy online
trusted overseas pharmacies
canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
Really plenty of great advice.
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
prescription drugs without prior prescription canadian pharmacies canada drugs online pharmacy canadian pharmaceuticals online
canadapharmacyonline.com
global pharmacy canada
canada drug pharmacy
medication costs
online drugs
pharmacy drug store
Thank you. Very good information!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
drugs from canada canadianpharmacy prescription drugs prices aarp approved canadian online pharmacies
canada pharmacy online orders
online pharmacy without prescription
canada drugs online pharmacy
prescription drug
buying prescription drugs canada
overseas pharmacy forum
Kudos. Excellent stuff!
http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
canada pharmacies online pharmacy canada pharmaceuticals online canadapharmacyonline.com canada pharmacy
canadian mail order pharmacies
get prescription online
pharmacy without dr prescriptions
canada pharmacy online reviews
us pharmacy no prior prescription
cheap canadian drugs
Tips effectively utilized!!
http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
canadapharmacy canadian online pharmacies pharmacy online canadianpharmacy
northwest pharmacy
canadian pharmacies without prescriptions
most reliable canadian pharmacies
buy prescription drugs from canada
drugs from canada
prescription drug
Thanks a lot! Quite a lot of material!
http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
medication costs canadian pharmacies without an rx canada online pharmacies canadian pharmacies without an rx
online rx pharmacy
pharmacy online
cialis canadian pharmacy
pharmacy canada
canada pharmacy online no script
pharmacy drug store
Kudos, Useful information!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
canadian drug northwest pharmacy no prescription online pharmacy canadian pharmacies-24h
most reliable canadian pharmacies
canadian pharcharmy online
canadadrugs.com pharmacy
pharmacies near me
prescription drug
cheap canadian drugs
Whoa lots of awesome data!
http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/
online pharmacy without prescription canadian pharmaceuticals online canadapharmacyonline com canadian online pharmacies
prescription cost
best price prescription drugs
approved canadian pharmacies online
safe canadian online pharmacies
online canadian pharmacy
compare prescription prices
You revealed it exceptionally well!
http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
canada drugs online canadian pharmacies that ship to us mexican pharmacies northwest pharmacy
discount prescription drug
buy online prescription drugs
canadian discount pharmacy
mexican pharmacies online
ed meds online
prescription drugs online without doctor
Nicely put. Appreciate it!
http://talahicc.com/
rx price comparison canadian pharmacies online canada pharmacies online pharmacy canada pharmaceutical online ordering
pharmacy canada
mexican online pharmacies
approved canadian pharmacies online
online pharmacy no prescription needed
canadapharmacy
meds online
You’ve made your stand very effectively.!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canadian discount pharmacy canadian pharmacy online canadian cialis canadian pharmaceuticals online
get prescription online
canadian pharmacies top best
canadian pharcharmy online
prescription drug cost
trusted overseas pharmacies
canadian pharmacies without prescriptions
Very well spoken without a doubt! .
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
canadian pharmacy viagra brand canada drugs online king pharmacy canada drugs
online canadian pharmacies
pharmacy canada
canada online pharmacies
online pharmacy without a prescription
discount pharmacy online
trust pharmacy canada
Lovely data, Regards!
http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
canada pharmacy online no script mexican pharmacies shipping to usa canadian pharma companies canadian pharmacies that ship to us
mail order pharmacies
canadapharmacyonline com
canadian family pharmacy
online pharmacy without prescription
canadian drug store
canadian pharmacies that are legit
Good write ups. Thank you!
http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
us pharmacy no prior prescription canadian pharmacies-24h canadian pharmacies that are legit canadian pharmacies online
mexican pharmacy online
online rx pharmacy
trusted overseas pharmacies
mexican pharmacies online
discount pharmacy online
prescription drug cost